And Now For Something Completely Different: The Fake Bourjaily Book of Thanksgiving Horror Stories
I wanted to do a Thanksgiving themed post, but I can only think of a couple Thanksgiving stories off the top of my head. One of them is Johnny Compton's exemplary "No Hungry Generations", which we talked about in the spring.
But also...the blog here is "Reading and Writing" short horror fiction, but there hasn't been much sign of that writing yet. I do (sometimes) write my own stuff, but since I'm trying to get it sold, I can't put it up here. So let me do something different, which is a mostly fake anthology of Thanksgiving horror stories.
Here's the game: This is a standard blogpost; I list a bunch of stories from a book, give a brief synopsis, and then share some thoughts about the story. Except... all but one of these stories is an affectionate parody of a horror writer whose work I know and love enough to do an at least passable pastiche (and the 'criticism/thoughts' are therefore fake as well). One of the stories is mostly real, and I'm giving the actual synopsis and my actual thoughts. Why "mostly?" Well, the real story is perfect for the list except for the pesky fact that it doesn't take place on Thanksgiving, but I've retitled it and tweaked the synopsis slightly. However, if you've read the story, you should be able to figure it out.
The emphasis is on affectionate, not parody: These writers are all great and I've covered nearly all of them on here so far. Similarly, the one author whose real story I'm cheekily suggesting could be a pastiche is a personal favorite, so please don't think I'm suggesting they're self-parodic.
Enjoy, then, and see if you can spot the "right" one!
"Gobble Gobble" by Clay McLeod Chapman
Synopsis: Suburban everydad Jay is in charge of bringing Thanksgiving dinner across the finish line while wife Melissa does some last-minute wine shopping. An episode of gluttonous hunger leaves Jay looking for something to serve to the rest of the family.
Thoughts: Chapman goes back to the oral fixation well again, with powerful results. A lot of the milage here is less from the (frankly, slightly tacked on) bizarro horror of the end, as much as the fear and panic over having indulged in an "Imp of the Perverse" moment and trying to cover it up. That's relatable. The turkey baster scene, not so much, although I'd love to see him read this one live.
"A Superman Big As The Sky" by Ray Bradbury
Synopsis: Death has come for Grandmom Rose; Edwin tries to distract him by getting him to watch football and the parade.
Thoughts: Late-period Bradbury could still produce the hits (he also produced, in my opinion, too much poetry). In general, I don't think of him as someone slipping into self-parody, because there's always an awareness and an honesty behind the sentiment. After all, isn't the wicked genius of "Mars Is Heaven" in large part how much it plays like a mean parody of a Bradbury tale?
Anyway, this is a theme that Bradbury played around with various times--off the top of my head, "I Sing the Body Electric," "There Was An Old Woman," "Memento Mori" and even, in a roundabout way, "Fee Fie Fo Fum." The child's-eye view here (like "I Sing") adds some additional color, and gives Bradbury a chance to conjure up a vintage Midwestern Thanksgiving. It's not particularly horrific, or even really a "dark fantasy," but it's very likable.
"A Home in the Hills" by Dennis Etchison
Synopsis: Aspiring Hollywood writer John Fenn expects to spend another LA Thanksgiving eating fast food, but a producer's daughter brings him to her family's mansion in the Hollywood Hills for dinner.
Thoughts: John probably should have gone to the Weenie Wigwam (part of the Etchison Expanded Universe; it pops up in Darkside and some other places as well) after all, although the mind boggles at the potential for cultural insensitivity, considering. Anyway. . .
As Etchison's "it isn't 'horror,' but it's horror" stories about the Hollywood meat grinder go, it's better than "The Last Reel" but nowhere near as good as "The Dog Park." I guess this is the story that people who like "The Blood Kiss" think "The Blood Kiss" is.
What's interesting in all three of these stories, and some of the other showbiz tales like "The Spot" and "Bloodgame" is how it relates to Doug Winter's statement that horror is an emotion, not a genre. I think if I'd read this ten or fifteen years ago, I would have been disappointed that it doesn't literally payoff the set-up. Now I'm glad. Day of the Locust doesn't need a literal giant locust attacking Hollywood to be a work of horror, you know?
"The Wind Came Down and Cut Me from Your Side" by Charles L. Grant
Synopsis: Middle-aged widower Lionel chooses Thanksgiving dinner with his son's girlfriend's family (including her comely older sister) over his usual visit to childhood friend Grace.
Thoughts: I know, I keep promising I'm done covering Grant, but his stories just keep popping up! And what a title; it's iambic pentameter this time.
This is another Grant love triangle story with an "Am I Past My Prime? I'm Not Sure. These Two Women Don't Seem To Think So" theme, which seems to afflict every man (and, if you flip the sexes, more than a few women) in Oxrun Station, Connecticut, between the ages of, oh, 19 and 79.
Back to the story--it is good, but here the supernatural element seems a bit shoehorned in. I say seems because I don't think it is as arbitrary as it seems; rather, I think it's that I spent last month reading the Oxrun Quartet, which at least hints at causality for much of the goings-on, and I'm instinctively looking for it here.
Maybe this is all a coping mechanism to deal with the last few lines, which reminded me of the most haunting moment of Grant's most haunting story ("A Garden of Blackred Roses," which we'll get to one day).
"The Harvest Parade" by Thomas Ligotti
Synopsis: A loner in a Detroit apartment is disquieted when the black and white TV shows a clown balloon in the local Thanksgiving day parade. It gets worse when it floats out of his television.
Thoughts: It's hard to think of Ligotti as a fun time holiday guy (unless such holiday is The Feast of Harlequin or the Greater Festival of Masks). "Conversations in a Dead Language" is a great Halloween story, but Thanksgiving?
What stands out about this story, and what I think sometimes goes underacknowledged in discussions of Ligotti, is just how good his sense of place is. All the pessimistic philosophy and darkly comic commentary would not hit as hard without being anchored to something physical, and the grotesque decay depicted in stories like "Purity" and, to a lesser extent, "Gas Station Carnivals" contributes to the sense of an overall diseased existence.
It almost works too well--the crummy desperation of the setting makes the arrival of the clown balloon almost a relief, because anything that relieves us from this bleak Thanksgiving-for-one is a relief.
"Giving Thanks" by Elizabeth Massie
Synopsis: Ruth and her brother are out on one of the most important holiday errands: Bringing back a batch of Blue Ridge Oysters!
Thoughts: Gleefully repulsive, which is a compliment around these parts. You can probably tell what Blue Ridge Oysters are; if not, take a look at a map and think about it.
What I really like about this story, and the antics of our Blue Ridge Oyster Cult, is the efficiency of violence: I've read this story a bunch (it's quick) and I'm always convinced I've seen something graphic and disgusting when there's very little description on the page. Like Psycho, The Texas Chain Saw Massacre, and Reservoir Dogs, it's impossible to shake the feeling that you've seen much more than you actually have.
"Abominations Away" by Matthew M. Bartlett
Synopsis: Western Massachusetts' unholiest radio station, KXXP gives back to the community with a Thanksgiving air drop of. . . something.
Thoughts: Nobody says "God as my witness, I thought shoggoths could fly," because 1) why would you think they could, and 2) these aren't exactly shoggoths (and, while we're at it, I'm not exactly sure any God you'd trust as a witness is in Bartlett's universe, either). But, otherwise, this is a very fun, very cheeky WKRP in Cincinnati riff with Bartlett's own inimitable style. Recommended, if you can track it down.
"A Turkee" by John Skipp
Synopsis: The thought of spending Thanksgiving at a strip club in any capacity is a bleak one, but Robbie, the proprietor of The Naked Jaybird, has a bright idea: Gravy wrestling! Unfortunately for everyone involved, Robbie's not the best at sourcing gravy in bulk.
Thoughts: Another rarity, and a fun one.
What you can see in here (and later comes out in the novel-length The Long Last Call) is Skipp's compassion for all people, even (especially?) the marginalized and easy to stereotype. In relatively little space, Skipp gives humanity to the dancers and patrons, few of whom ever dreamed of spending Thanksgiving afternoon somewhere like this. As a result, while the profondo grosso carnage that follows lives up to Skipp's splat reputation (think Blood Freak but made by Russ Meyer, and you're on the right track), it's leavened with a sense of loss for the men and women of The Naked Jaybird.
Okay, folks. So, which one is the real story?
The answer is "Giving Thanks," by Beth Massie; it's actually just called "Thanks". However, I cheated a little: Massie's story takes place before Christmas, not Thanksgiving, but it works really well for the game, and who wants to let a pesky thing like the truth get in the way? This nauseating non-November nugget appeared first in Lore #8 in 1998, and then in Rod Heather & Sean O'Leary's anthology LORE in 2011. It's also in the rare (but very much worth it) The Fear Report, which is a big anthology combining some of Massie's greatest hits with a bunch of rarities.
Happy Thanksgiving!

Comments
Post a Comment